updated 12/9/2003

Phil 1105.003Critical Thinking (W)


Fall 2003

TR 3:30


Michael Eldridge  Garinger 209
704/687-3318

mleldrid@email.uncc.edu
Office Hours: M 2-3; TR 2:00-3:20

 (and by appointment)

Course Materials consist primarily of various readings and a glossary, which are available on the instructor's website: http://www.uncc.edu/mleldrid  

Course Description: Various concepts and techniques are taught in order that students may employ them in evaluating a variety of materials. Students will be expected initially to produce a portfolio of some of these critical thinking tools, then, following an exam, they will employ these tools in evaluating an issue for exam 2, writing a paper and taking a final exam.

 

Schedule

Date

Day

Topic

Assignment

August

26

Tues

Introduction to the Course

 

28

Thur

"What the Doctor Ordered"

alternatives, appearance and reality and critical awareness

September

2

Tues

The Possibility of Criticism

Exam Answers, "Really Right" and "A Dissertation Upon Roast Pig"; also criterion, critical thinking, criticism and inconsistency

4

Thur

"Next at 11: More Mayhem and Misery" 

explanation

9 Tues Appearance & Reality Examples

11

Thur

Examples: Definitions

definition and Texas Icehouses

16

Tues

Examples: Alternatives/Criteria and Explanations

18

Thur

Catch Up and Review

19 Fri The Portfolio is DUE by noon in the instructor's office or his box in the Philosophy Dept. office, Winn 103.  NOTE: The portfolio shall consist of four explained examples of the appearance/reality distinction, use of alternatives and criterion, a definition and an explanation. (Definitions and examples can be found in the glossary.)  This does not need to be elaborate; nor do you need a cover page.

23

Tues

Explanations, Arguments and Fallacies

"Ignoring the Constitution"; argument and links; Begging the Question; fallacy

25

Thur

Sticking to the Point

Red Herring and Straw Man

30

Tues

Meaning and Definition

"Who Needs the WWW?", "Most Religious Century" and ambiguity, definition, equivocation and vagueness

October

2

Thur

False Dichotomy and Groups and Individuals

Kids and Choices; false dichotomy; composition and division; examples of possible fallacies are available

7

Tues

Student Reactions to Eldridge and his CT Course

empirical or inductive generalizations, false cause, hasty generalization and slippery slope

9

Thur

Analogies and

"Who's To Say?"

argument from analogy, inductive and weak analogy;

appeal to authority, personal attack and appeal to ignorance and consistency

14

Tues

Fall Break - No Class

16

Thur

Exam 1

The exam will consist of identification questions on the concepts and fallacies we have covered.

21

Tues

Alabama Biology Textbook Insert

http://www.eagleforum.org/educate/2001/dec01/al-insert.shtml

23 Thur Difficulty of this Course

Two Responses  

28 Tues Reason for Iraq War http://abcnews.go.com/sections/nightline/US/globalshow_030425.html
http://www.cqs.com/iraq.htm
http://www.rnc.org/Newsroom/GOPTopline/Oct03/topline100803.htm
http://www.44thdems.org/DemGazette/Sept2003/Iraq.html
30 Thur Issue Discussion
November

4

Tues

Issue Discussion

Boone Report
http://www.thepublicinterest.com/archives/2002fall/article3.html
http://www.drissman.com/blog/archives/2003/04/07/winter_break_in_england.html
http://www.texansforgunsafety.org/articles/archives/Britain.htm
Last Semester's Exam 2

6

Thur

Take Home Exam

Criticism of one of the issues discussed in class; students will also describe their paper projects (topic, approach and sources); DUE Friday, November 7

11 Tues Exam 2 will be returned in class on Tuesday, November 11.  For the rest of this period and through 17 November, students will have the opportunity to meet individually with the instructor (in his office) to review the exam and discuss the paper project.  Appointments at other times will also be available.
13 Thur
18 Tues

no class

instructor in Cuba

20 Thur

no class

25 Tues Paper DUE by beginning of class, but there will be no class meeting.  Papers should be placed in the instructor's box in Winn 103 or emailed as MS Word attachments to mleledrid@email.uncc.edu.
27 Thur Thanksgiving - No Class
December
2 Tues Papers Returned
4 Thur No Class
9 Tues Review: Questions Answered
18 Thur Take Home Final Exam DUE: 3:30 p.m.

 

 

                Grade Composition

Portfolio

Exam 1

Exam 2

Paper

Final

Participation

15%

20%

15%

20%

20%

10%

 

 

Grade Scale

90-100 is an A

80-89 is a B

70-79 is a C

60-69 is a D

59 and below is a F



 

Attendance and Participation Policy

Attendance is expected. Irregular attendance will negatively impact the student's participation grade. Students who make a contribution to the class will be rewarded. Contributions include providing examples of the concepts, techniques and fallacies studied in the class, asking and answering questions in class, participating in class discussions and group projects, including study groups. Students may present--in writing--evidence of their participation at the end of the course (but prior to the exam period).

 

NOTE

The instructor reserves the right to modify the course and its requirements as conditions warrant. Students will be notified of changes either in class or online or preferably in both ways.

 

Academic Integrity

Students have the responsibility to know and observe the requirements of "The UNC Charlotte Code of Student Academic Integrity" (UNC Charlotte Catalog 2001-3, p. 275). The most recent edition of the Code is available in the Office of the Dean of Students.

 

Disability Accommodation

Students with documented disabilities requiring accommodation in this course should contact Disability Services in Fretwell 230.

 

Goal Statement

This section is writing intensive and meets some of the requirements of Goal I: Communication. UNC Charlotte graduates should be able to:

·         Effectively send and receive in English written and oral messages in different situations for a variety of audiences, purposes and subjects.

·         Communicate effecively in a symbolic system of language (other than English) having written, oral or visual components.

 Philosophy Majors and Others Interested in Philosophy

Students majoring in Philosophy or considering a major in Philosophy are encouraged to retain a copy of their research paper and exams for possible inclusion in the Portfolio required of majors. This information is available on the web at Philosophy Program, and copies are available in the Department of Philosophy (103 Winningham).

 

Students are invited to participate via email in an electronic philosophy discussion list for students. To join Phil-D, send your email address to mjcroy@email.uncc.edu and request to be added.

 Back to CT home page

Copyright © 2003, Michael Eldridge